Mystic Hills Golf Course  

Mystic Hill Golf Course Inc.
16788 20B RD
CULVER, IN 46511
(574) 842-2687

15.93 SW 1/4 SW 1/4 EX S 1RD EX E S 16' SW SW SW 19.99 acres - A REPLAT OF LOTS 1-5 MYSTIC HILLS ESTATES PUD 32.53 - NW SW EX EX 38.63 SW1/4 SW1/4 EX 71.845 W1/2 NW1/4 EX

? -2005, Nov. Paul E & Joyce E Winn

It has 18 holes and has a links-style look on the front nine and more challenging holes on the back. It plays 6,795 yards from the tips.

Mystic Hills Golf Course was built and open for business in 1998. The golf course founder was Wayne Bonnell of Star City, Indiana (owner of Pond View Golf at Star City) and course architect was Pete Dye.

The owner of Mystic Hills, Wayne Bonnell, approached Pete & Alice Dye about the desire of building the golf course in Culver and invited Pete Dye to be the golf course's architect. After a negotiation process, Pete Dye agreed to be the courses architect. Dye has said it took only about $1 million to get this one built. He designed it while working with his son P.B.

2007, Jan - 2011, Sep. - SAJV INC

2008-2010 - Listed as Lculever Golf Course

2011, Sep-2019 - Mystic Hills Golf Course, Inc.

Mystic Hills was purchased by Wayne and Mary Lou's daughter, Vicki Pugh, in 2011.

2014 - Vicki's son, Dave Pugh, currently serves as the PGA Professional and the course superintendent.

They’ve just begun the process of creating a stay-and-play opportunity

?- 2007 - Jan - Wayne F & Mary Lou Bonnell and Steven W. & Stephanie Bonnell

2019,Feb-2024 - Kaserlie LLC - James S. Irsay, member; Dan Emerson (Chief Legal Officer, Indianapolis Colts), Agent

It is said: - 1 year ago Jim Irsay purchases Mystic Hills Golf Course in Culver!

Just heard from an employee of the Mystic Hills Golf Course in Culver, Indiana that Jim Irsay has purchased the course for just over $1 million.

The course will remain open to the public until the end of this season and beginning the 1st of January it will be closed for 2 years while Mr. Irsay brings the course up to his standards.

Rumor is, that the GC will no longer be open to the public.

This is sad to hear, considering that this was one of Indiana's premier golf courses and one that was designed by Pete Dye
Mystic Hills Golf Club Culver, Indiana Restored and renovated the golf course for a June, 2020 re-opening of the front nine for the Indianapolis Colts owner, Jim Irsay. Golf course had been closed for a couple of years Completed a thorough 50-page analysis and due diligence review for a prospective buyer group in February, 2018 Cohoat and O’Neal Management Corp.

Jun 8, 2022 - The Pete Dye Golf Course,Mystic Hills in Culver,Indiana has been renamed HorseShoe arms and now is The Longest Golf Course in the World- Par

Jun 9, 2022 - Jim Irsay on Twitter: "FYI…if I didn't buy Mystic Hills Golf Course(Pete Dye designed)... in the beautiful Northern Indiana lake town of Culver…