Cottage History & Index from 1953 to Present
1919 - July 2 - Report shows 146 cottages on 196 Lake Lots
1953 was the first year that the lake directories were issued and gave a
listing of all lake residents (or houses).
This was my "FIRST" working outline of the site along with listings from Lake
Directories that were in the Marshall County Historical Society; there were
but a few scattered issues from 1953-September 1990 when I started on this
project.
From these I have worked backwards and forwards with what I could find; to trying
and make a complete listing of the cottages and lake parcels and create a history
for each if at all possible.
The label as "non lakefront" is not meant to offend anyone - nor is it meant to be
taken that it does not have lake access it could very well have, I have not deleved
into that aspect unless it has been noted in a descrption of the property as having
a legal access to the lake - the only meaning intended is that the house/cottage
and or property is NOT directly located on the shoreline/shores of Lake Maxinkuckee
aka "lake side" of the road - or thus directly connected to the Lake Maxinkuckee it
means only that there is a road and/or alley betweenit and the lake.
Nothing within is set in "STONE" and everything is subject to change when documentation
is found - through deeds, newspaper articles. etc and has over the yeaars and will
continue to as I delve further into Lake Maxinkuckee's and Culver's history. This is an
ever changing project and site as new material surfaces. It is a never ending project
that I will never see completed in my lifetime.
Some topic of interest:
East North of Maxinkuckee Landing
401 East Shore Drive - - Woodcraft Camp & part of the Golf course (16.069A);
built in 1963
|
446 East Shore Drive (480/504) - Culver Farm House / Culver Place -
Culver Educational Foundation
Culver Homestead - more pictures and the above history.
18A this includes the Culver Military Boathouse
N 1169.5FT S 1549.5 FT LOT 3 & R W RD
|
| |
461 (475) - East Shore Drive - Culver Academy Golf Course , 60.080A.
LOT 3 EX PT W OF RD 35A /26.650A is Golf Course
N 31.27A LOT 4 EX 20.77A/18.270A is Golf Course
S PT N 31.27A LOT 4 E RD 6.5A/5.160A Golf course
|
521 East Shore Drive Vacant lot - was the CMA Barn - now
represented by an empty lot of the west side - burned sometime between 1987
when it was listed in the lake directory and 1989 it was between spring and
fall of the year.
A very early photo as it possibly looked from standing on the Golf course
area the back side of the barn that was located on the edge of the golf course
N 31.27A LOT 4 EX 20.77A/18.270A is Golf Course
|
|
|
531 E. Shore - Culver Educational Fundation - non lake front |
641 East Shore Drive - Was CMA Appartments North now represented by a bare lot
|
|
681 East Shore Drive - Knight K. Culver Cottage, built c. 1923
& was purchased in 1935 & turned into the "Golf Club Hotel (House)".
(non-lakefront)
Culver Educational Foundation Faculty
Apartments (non-lakefront) |
686 East Shore Drive
694 East Shore Drive v
728 East Shore Drive
751 East Shore Drive (non-lakefront)
782 East Shore Drive
845 East Shore Drive (non-lakefront)
|
|
Peru Club
is said to have been built about 1878.
898 East Shore Drive
.
|
| Shady Bluff |
1040 East Shore Drive
1054 East Shore Drive - Toad House
1070 East Shore Drive - 1952-1953 - R. L. Babcock
Caretaker cottage of Marmon estate
1961 - - O. T. Smith
1979 - 2005- 2007 - - address not listed
26 March 1958 Culver Citizen:
Ronald L. Babcock, age 72, lifelong resident of the Culver community and father
of George Babcock, manager of the Marshall Co. Lumber Company here, died last
Friday at the Miller nursing home in Rochester. Mr. Miller [sic Babcock] lived at
1070 East Shore Dr. on Lake Maxinkuckee where for years he had been caretaker of
the Marmon estate there. He was also a member of the Maxinkuckee Methodist Church
and the Maxinkuckee IOOF lodge #373.
1085_ East Shore Drive -
[1075] Greenleaf Log House Marmon Estate/Orchard House (non-lakefront)
1110 East Shore Drive
1120 East Shore Drive
1200 East Shore Drive - 1956-61 - Dewey Mc Farland
1958 - Dewey McFarland 1200 East Shore Drive, Culver.
2005-2007 not listed
1206 East Shore Drive -
Holly Hill / HOLLY HILL INVESTORS LLC
___ East Shore Drive - vacant lots (Non-lakefront
1207 East Shore Dr.
- "Fairview" - Razed 1960's
1236 East Shore Drive - 1953 - Heekin [Not listed 1993, 2005-2007]
1249 - 1958 Lake Director - Mrs. Elizabeth B. Crawford
1521 S. Center St., Terre Haute, lnd
1274 - 1958 Lake Directory - Mrs. Hattie Alice Hale 919 S. Fifth St.,
West Terre Haute, Ind.
1275 East Shore Drive
1296 - 1958 Lake Directory - Hale (Rental) - 19 S. Fifth St., Terre Haute, Ind.
1297 - 1958 Lake Directory - C. C. Wynn
-- [1301] East Shore Drive - ? Jul 1998 - (Vacant Lots non-lakefront)
1346 East Shore Drive
Razed - new dwelling in 1970-1980's & it was razed
Barbara Ann Sheerin Rocap - razed
1352 S. J. Rossa Grocery
- 1352 East Shore Drive, Culver. 1958 Lake Directory - Razed (became a part of 1346
1355 East Shore Drive - Vacant lot
razed 1985 - formerly Manor Market and Apartments
NASWAWKEE- Reservation in Marshall County, bordering Lake Maxinkuckee.
The hill rising from Maxinkuckee landing is still known as Nas-wae-kee's Hill...pg.
288 True Indian Stories with Glossary of Indiana Indian Names By Jacob Piatt Dunn
1909. Foot of Naswawkee Hill, Lake Maxinkuckee, showing cemeted reataining wall of
glacial boulders. McDonald's
Lake history |
|
Maxinkuckee Landing
Easement to lake - and 18th Rd. going east from St. Rd. 117
The East side Historic District
- the official recording of this is: Also known Lake Maxinkuckee Historic District -
Roughly, E Shore Dr. from W. 18th Rd., to the E turn of IN 117, including Maxinkuckee
Club, Culver. But another map I found expands it further north of the landing.
Maxinkuckee Landing Area
Maxinkuckee Landing, Index
Maxinkuckee Landing History
Richard Jesse Bright
John Bigley's: Maxinkuckee Launches
Lee R. Finney
Thomas Bigley
Chester Bigley
1355 [1352] East Shore Dr -
Vans Market / RJ's / Manor Market
Allegheny House
East South of Maxinkuckee Landing
Sea Beach Place
Subdivision (1898); it takes in the cottages 1380 to 1570.
1380 East Shore Drive
1394 East Shore Drive
1412 East Shore Drive
2016 - Razed and New dwelling
- James C. Courtney
1424East Shore Drive
1444 East Shore Drive
1450 East Shore Drive
1460 East Shore Drive
1470 East Shore Drive
|
Lake access - there is to be a access site here - but for as long as I can remember it has been grass
covered and has had trees and brush overgrown in it - David Burns also stated that it was lake access
when he worked on constructing the sea wall in the late 1970's or early 1980's; as some of the brush
had to be trimmed back to gain access to the lake front in order to pour cement. It is shown of the
plat maps of the past and present. |
1480 East Shore Dr.
1550 East Shore Drive
formerly a apart of 1480 E. Shore Portledge Cottage
1530 East Shore Drive
1540 East Shore Drive
1556 East Shore Drive
1570 East Shore Drive
1614 East Shore Drive - Razed/Rebuilt
1630 East Shore Drive
1640 East Shore Drive -
Greenleaves - Treaty Hill
1650 East Shore Drive
1653 (1641) E Shore Dr
Maxinkuckee Country Club
1718 e. Shore Dr.
Aubbeenaubbee Creek - now refered to as Curtiss Ditch The Curtiss Wetland
followed in 1990, creating a 12-acre natural area east of the lake on land owned
by Arthur and Nancy Baxter, this was not riginally a wetland, but pasture land
along Aubbeenaubbee Creek now known as Curtiss Ditch ..."The environmental
council and the Baxters, owners of the land on which the Curtiss was built, have
not always agreed on goals and their implementation. Of concern for the Baxters
was a growth of underwater plants that limited open water for canoeing and fishing,
but which the LMEC felt was
performing the job of filtering nutrients. During 1999, the Baxters introduced
triploid (sterile) grass carp to curb what they describe as a smelly brown
mass in the water and scum on the surface."- Lake Maxinkuckee Restored Wetlands
Fred Karst
It is and is not listed on Plat maps for some reason. To the right is the 1990 listing
and an aerial view as of 2007 current photo of the area. |
|
|
1711 - 1958 Lake Directory -
Reason C. Eaton - near Maxinkuckee Golf Course
1746 East Shore Drive
The Ball Cottage
1766 East Shore Drive
1784 East Shore Drive
1790 East Shore Drive
1814 East Shore Drive
1820 East Shore Drive
1840 East Shore Drive
1870 East Shore Drive -
1880 East Shore Drive
1910 East Shore Drive "The Fish House" Razed/Rebuilt
1930 East Shore Drive
1940 East Shore Drive
1954 East Shore Drive Razed 2018
1970 East Shore Drive
02002_e_shore
2008 East Shore Drive
2014 East Shore Drive
2044 East Shore Drive
2074 East Shore Drive - Seven Gables
2100 East Shore Drive - Westwind
1958 Lake Directory - Mrs. Clyde R. Roach /Charles A. Rockwood -
Mrs. Clyde J. Roach (East 2080) (See Charles A. Rockwood, East 2080).;
Charles A. Rockwood (East 2080) 1739 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, Ind.
Clyde Jefferson Roach
Rockwood Family
2114 East Shore Drive
2118 East Shore Drive Razed and absorbed by adjoining properties
2124 East Shore Drive
2130 East Shore Drive
2160 East Shore Drive
2176 East Shore Drive
2210 East Shore Drive
2220 East Shore Drive
|
|
2250 East Shore Drive
It is believe that here was the location othe the "Indianapolis Pier" that the
steamers docked at.
|
2253 East Shore Drive
East Shore Lane
|
In 1928, the East Shore neighborhood
Association Inc. was formed. This is the area known as the "Private Drive".
Its main purpose was to maintain and keep that area - private. There is a wooded
called that was at one time called "Rice Woods"
to the east that was turned over to the association |
2270 East Shore Lane
|
____ East Shore Lane - - (Rice's Woods) - East Shore Lane Association
Lot2 W RD E 30'EX RICE SUB
|
2276 East Shore Lane
2296 East Shore Lane
2306 East Shore Lane
2314 East
2437 - 1958 - Maxinkuckee Playhouse / Paul Rutledge
2348 East Shore Lane
2358 East Shore Lane
2370 East Shore Lane
2380 East Shore Lane
By the 1922 Plat map VanSchoiacks Sub. No. #3 was to have lots 14-25; by the
descriptions of cottages 2306-2380 Lots 14-22 exists of this orginial plat. Lots 23-25
became a part of CORNELIUS & EWING SUB; just when it was replated as such is unknown to
date.
The history from 1922 back is based on the lot size and comparing the 1922 plat against
today's plat the only true accurate account yet is to come from deeds and abstracts, plat
maps of post 1922. |
|
2410 East Shore Lane
2420 East Shore Lane
2434 East Shore Lane [2434 East Shore Lane]
2450 East Shore Lane
|
2461 East Shore Lane (Rice Woods) |
|
2485 East Shore Lane |
2502 [2501] East Shore Lane
2517 East Shore Lane (Rice Woods)
|
2519 East Shore Lane (Rice Woods) |
2546 East Shore Lane 1953 - not listed
1956-8 - J. F. Crabb / 1958 Lake Directory - 2546 J. F. Crabb - 2546 East Shore Lane,
1979, 1985-7 - not listed
Lake access/Edwards Lane
|
2552 East Shore Lane James F. & Emily Sturman, trustees |
Edwards Lane
|
Edwards Lane runs from East Shore Lane to St. Rd 117. It is a county road
and was not maintained for many years. It was communicated that "Until the late
1980s, Edwards Lane was closed and totally overgrown. At some point (for reasons
that escape) in the late 1980s, the county decided to re-open Edwards Lane and cut
through the woods that had overtaken." This so-called "unknown reason" most
logically was probably for faster emergency access to those houses on the lower
portion of the East Shore Lane and eliminating the rough ride ovet the "speed bumps"
that existed. |
2655 East Shore Drive
2744 [2742]2655 East Shore Drive
1958 Lake Directory - 2744 Mrs. Emmet E. Rose - 2153 Barth Ave., Indianapolis Ind.
East Shore Lane
East Shore neighborhood Association Inc
Rice Woods
2270 East Shore Lane
2276 East Shore Lane - Willow Spring
2296 East Shore Lane
2306 East Shore Lane
2314 East Shore Lane
2324 East Shore Lane
2348 East Shore Lane
2358 East Shore Lane
2380 East Shore Lane
2388 East Shore Lane to have been razed c . 1993 & re-built.
2410 East Shore Lane
2420 East Shore Lane
Razed/Rebuilt
2425 East Shore Lane
(Rice Woods)
2434 E Shore Lane -
Razed/absored into 2420 E. Shore Ln.
2437 E. Shore Dr. -
Maxinkuckee Playhouse / Paul Rutledge
2450 East Shore Lane
2470 East Shore Lane
2480 East Shore Lane <
2502 [2501]East Shore Lane
2517 East Shore Lane
2520 East Shore Lane
2536 East Shore Lane
-Razed/Rebuilt
2548 East Shore Lane
2550 East Shore Lane
2552 East Shore Lane
2556 East Shore Lane
2557 East Shore Lane
2558 East Shore Lane
2562 East Shore Lane
Thomas C. & Jean G. Barnes - Razed/Rebuilt
2628 East Shore Lane
- Razed/Rebuilt - 2628 & 2710 were one lot
2565 Edwards Lane
2655 East Shore Lane
2673 (2573) East Shore Dr -
Bide-A-Wee Hotel / Rowe's Inn / East Shore Inn - demolished
2710 East Shore Lane
Eagle Has Landed I & II
Woodbank - Razed
2740 East Shore /
the old "The Bean Patch"
East Shore Drive / St. Rd. 117
From East Shore Lane Entrance Curve
There are houses on St. Rd. 117 but do not really consider them part of the lake
properties presay. The Marinia (which was part of the Norris property which went to
the lake.) and the Norris house are considered to be lake properties as they were in
the past. I have added the Airport since it was a part of history that never flew and
the new Golf course and a new propsed subdivision since it is part of the Marina/Norris
properties of the past
2744 - 1958 Lake Directory - Mrs. Emmet E. Rose 2153 Barth Ave., Indianapolis, Ind.
2770 - 1958 Lake Directory - Dr. A. A. Norris - 401 W. Marion St., Elkhart, lnd
|
Manchester College Art Collection
Title: Approach to the Lake (Lake Maxinkuckee looking west from the marina)
Artist: Theodore E. Good |
This is within the Culver Marina area - and would of been the location of the proposed
Maxinkuckee Village
develpoement in 2009. The property is owned by Gary Aker, of Aker Properties, LLC. This proposed
project seems to be a dead issue now and will not be coming about - but it is a part
of the history and what could of been.
Horseshore Farms AKA Mystic Hills Golf Course
|
< |
|
Public golf course, club and facility designed by Pete Dye, which opened June
26, 1998. Starts at the edge of the marina property and streches down St. Rd.
117 to St. Rd. 110.
This course was built on the flat terrain. Putting and chipping contours and
various bunker shapes and slopes gives this course a classic look. The course
fits well within its natural surroundings of native grasses, meandering streams,
acres of wetlands, old forests and majestic hills. The Clubhouse sits at the
corner of 20thB & St. Rd. 117
The golf course is not defunct and was bought by James Irsay and renamed
"Horseshore Farms" |
East Shore ~ ~
Venetian Village ~ ~
South Shore ~ ~
West Shore ~ ~
West Shore Circle ~~
West Shore Town